Back to Home
arXiv AI··Papers & Tech

What Do Rationales Communicate? A Message-Intervention Study in Role-Specialized QA

中文摘要

研究探讨了角色分工问答流中,推理器传递给验证器的解释说明如何影响答案质量与支持评估,并引入了消息干预诊断方法。

English Summary

This study uses message-intervention diagnostics to investigate how rationales passed from reasoners to verifiers in specialized QA pipelines impact answer quality and support assessment.

Original Excerpt

arXiv:2610.00018v1 Announce Type: new Abstract: Role-specialized QA pipelines increasingly pass rationales from a reasoner to a verifier, but it is unclear what this message actually buys: better answers, stronger support assessment, or a new failure surface. We introduce a message-intervention diagnostic that fixes the evidence and candidate answer while varying only the rationale passed across the reasoner-to-verifier boundary. On 400 MuSiQue, HotpotQA, and 2WikiMultiHopQA examples with DeepSeek as generator and verifier, faithful rationales add almost no answer accuracy over no rationale, while corrupted rationales strongly alter support judgments. Under a blind verifier prompt, harmless paraphrases shift support by only 0--2.5%, whereas corrupted rationales shift support by 10--22%; an explicit rationale-checking prompt amplifies the same pattern to 34--55%. Final answers move less (2--30%), and only 2.9--35.3% of corrupted support flips co-occur with answer changes. Human audits show why this matters: 16/42 valid corruptions are corruption-overtrust cases, and blind humans reject or mark unclear 9/10 audited corrupted rationales that the model accepts. Cross-model and task-bou…